Why won't oil and water mix?
A hard shake makes one cloudy swirl. Wait a moment, and two layers return. What changes after the shaking stops?
Shaking makes drops, not a new liquid
The moving jar tears one oil layer into lots of tiny droplets. That cloudy look is oil spread through water.
Every tiny drop adds a boundary
same amount of oilone drop · shortest boundary
one big dropnine tiny drops
More drops means more oil touching water.
When oil drops meet, they join
bring the drops togetherfour drops · more boundary
apartjoined
One larger drop has less boundary than four small ones.
Scrub through one shake
shake storytwo calm layers
layerslayers return
Shaking changes droplet size. It does not make the oil dissolve.
Two matched jars share one clock
Same jars. Same shake. Only the right jar gets soap. Each tail tucks into oil while its water-loving head stays outside, so soap lines every droplet.
PLAIN JAR
SOAP JAR
What might those outer heads do to joining time?
Both jars get the same shake and the same settling time.
After the same shake, which jar clears into layers first?
Move one shared settling clock for both jars.
same clockboth jars cloudy
shaking stopslater on